Abstract this article captures the results of the best practices project and attempts to identify which ihrm practices are universally embraced in our ten. Convergence and divergence in asian hunnan resource managennent. B nowadays, there is an increasingly concern about convergence and divergence debate over human resource management practices of mncs that operate expandly accross the globe. Studies also suggest that the divergence of hr practices in french economies do not constitute convergence to an international human resource model. Convergence and divergence debate over ihrm practices term. Convergence and divergence in asian human resource management. Convergence and divergence in asian human resource. The divergence theory, on the other hand, argues that the sociocultural influences.
Convergence theory definition, discussion and examples. Despite all the pressures towards convergence, differences in cultural and trade union context produce divergent relationships. Studies suggest divergence of hr practices in asian economies e. Recognizing these types will help you decide which tests or strategies will be most useful in finding whether a series is convergent or divergent. Convergence and divergence debate over ihrm practices cram. Convergence and divergence of human resource management. The question of whether human resource management practices in organizations are becoming more similar i. Contextspecific analysis and future research agenda abstract highlighting the usefulness of conducting contextspecific hrm research, this article focuses on four themes. Contextspecific analysis and future research agenda abstract in this article, we highlight the significance and need for conducting contextspecific hrm research, by focusing on four critical themes. New measures of hrm convergencedivergence are developed using frequency distributions of hrm practices. Rising of mncs in global economy unifies hrm in global economies. Convergence or divergence between european hrm and american. With regard to convergence approach, it is generally accepted that the universality of sound management practices would lead to societies and countries becoming more and.
Convergence, divergence and crossvergence of hrm systems in. Convergence is useful if you consciously choose to spend time with people youd like to become more. The globalization of the field of human resource management hrm has led to some common changes in international hrm practices. This investigation concludes that there is indeed a convergence in the use of hrm for competitive advantage. Essay on convergence and divergence in the context of globalization assignment within the rhetoric of globalization and the economic theory surrounding it is a sense that many experts believe and espouse that income convergence is a logical outcome of globalized markets. The divergence hrm compares systems of one country with the other country and then identifies similarities and differences then forms the antecedents from those differences. The comparative hrm literature largely argues for divergence due to the embeddedness of. With regard to convergence approach, it is generally. Convergence and divergence of human resources uk essays.
Economic theories predict globalization mostly likely leads to growing divergence in hrm practices across. Human resource management hrm aims to achieve individual performance in order for firm performance. Globalization and convergencedivergence of hrm across. Pdf convergence or divergence between european human. The analysis is based on survey data gathered from 232 hrm managers from american, japanese and german top 500 companies. When the value of an asset, indicator, or index moves, the related asset, indicator, or index moves in the other direction. Social variables make european hrm divergent from american hrm. Divergence is the tendency of group members to become less like other group members over time. The international journal of human resource management. Jun 25, 2019 divergence is the opposite of convergence. The effects of market economy and foreign mne subsidiaries on. Crossvergence is an approach to hrm that combines both the convergence and divergence approaches and is the most common hrm practice in the world warner, 20. International human resource management defined tendencies toward international human.
Convergence and divergence issues in strategic management. Globalization and international trade and finance may place sub. As a matter of fact, it is extremely rare to find a multinational that practices either of the approaches in their pure form. The role of human resource management function is at the crossroad, and on the one hand it is facing the crisis whereas there also exists an unprecedented opportunity to redefine and refocus the hrm function to leverage its credibility in. Divergence, convergence, or crossvergence in international. Sep 30, 2019 convergence theory presumes that as nations move from the early stages of industrialization toward becoming fully industrialized, they begin to resemble other industrialized societies in terms of societal norms and technology. Human resource practices and policies for competitive advantage worldwide article pdf available in the international journal of human resource management 52. Convergence and divergence debate over ihrm practices bartleby. The convergence and divergence of hrm across nations the. New measures, explanatory theory, and nonstandard predictions from bringing in economics.
Major indicator of firm performance is business performance. Convergence and divergence issues in strategic management indonesias experience with the balanced scorecard in hr management. Divergence approach to ihrm contrary to convergence point of view which assumed that the differences of local practices in hrm were only the reflection of different stages of development and will be ultimately replaced by one best way, advocates of divergence outlook agreed that there were significant gaps in the context acting as. Globalization and convergence divergence of hrm across nations. Convergence and divergence dabate in europe 4215 words 17 pages human resource management as a concept was formalised in the usa in the late 1970s and early 1980s, encapsulated in two famous textbooks beer et al. Sep 28, 2017 contrary to convergence point of position which assumed that the differences of local patterns in hrm were merely the contemplation of different phases of development and will be finally replaced by one best manner, advocators of divergency mentality agreed that there were important spreads in the context playing as restraints on. The international journal of human resource management volume 5, 1994 issue 2. Nowadays, there is an increasingly concern about convergence and divergence debate over human resource management practices of mncs that operate expandly accross the globe. It is difficult to prescribe a hrm model without analyzing the regional and sociocontextual factors inherent in oman and neither convergence nor pure divergence.
Convergence and divergence in asian human resource management unholy tangle as the 1980s unfolded, with the resuh that widely varying styles of employee management have emerged. Multinational companies mncs provide convergence in hrm practices and national institutions and their law provide divergence in hrm. Convergence or divergence between european human resource. Hrm convergencedivergence trends are explained using economic theories from international trade and economic geography. Khan sultan qaboos university, oman the role of human resource management function is at the crossroad, and on the one hand it is facing the crisis whereas there also exists an unprecedented opportunity to redefine and refocus the hrm function. Convergence of hrm across national borders is, clearly, not a foregone conclusion. Aim of firms and managers are to achieve firm performance. In the convergence and divergence perspective, trade unions play a vital role in the use of international hrm practices. Many of the series you come across will fall into one of several basic types. Pdf globalization and convergencedivergence of hrm across. First, it highlights the need to analyze the contextspecific nature of hrm in asia in order to analyze the convergence divergence debate. The convergence and divergence not only represent different ways in which the international hrm is conducted but also reflects different tra. The debate concerning the observed reality of convergence divergence is rife within the hrm literatures. Striking a balance between globalization and localization in human resource management hrm requires a better understanding of the cross.
The convergence and divergence of hrm across nations. Convergence and divergence debate over ihrm practices by. First, we discuss the need to analyze the convergencedivergence debate on hrm in asiapacific. Pdf this paper advances theory development in international and comparative hrm regarding convergencedivergence trends in hrm. Deeper examination, however, reveals a different picture. Convergence and divergence issues in strategic management an asian perspective on the balanced scorecard in hr management abstract global competitive pressures shape an enterprises focus on strategic management systems, and in particular the balanced scorecard. The studies of rowley 1997 and rowley and benson 2002 indicated that disputable areas occurred regarding the evolution of asian hrm, namely, convergence or divergence in hrm of asiapacific. Human resource practices and policies for competitive advantage worldwide article pdf available in the international journal of human resource.
That is defined by devanna, fombrun, and tichy 1981. In this article, we ask if the emergence of human resource management hrm in china is a possibly unique case, or indeed even otherwise, in order to emphasize and add further evidence to the study of convergence, divergence and contextualization in the study. European firms are adopting firm performance orientation in hrm. Convergence or divergence 2 defined by devanna, fombrun, and tichy 1981. Though increasingly adopted in different countries our current knowledge concerning the global adoption of electronic human resource. Convergence is the tendency of group members to become more alike over time. Multinational companies mncs provide convergence in hrm practices and national institutions and their law provide of divergence in hrm.
1159 527 447 1550 1382 33 1487 416 449 156 862 141 1398 149 381 663 465 1138 1434 517 1269 1134 1457 216 429 604 72 1479 672 432 840 341 139 612 1326 157 1248 720 796 301 1049 660 413 711 801